There but for the grace of God go I
Posted by Heather on July 31, 2007
First, a heads up: Blogging here at the Mother Tongue has been a bit scarce for the last week or so, and it’ll continue to be so for the next few weeks while I work on my bit of a project for the arts department. My most sincere apologies, and believe me when I say I’d far rather spend my time lampooning my own parenting skills on this blog than working up an endless (but highly useful) music calendar. But, eh. C’est la vie.
In the meantime, why don’t you all just talk amongst yourselves about parenting in the news til we’re back up to 100% here?
Today’s discussion topic: What’s a fit punishment for parents who leave their kids to die in a hot car?
My thoughts: I’ve known several people whose children have died in terrible accidents, including one who spaced out and left a child in a hot car. I acknowledge that sometimes these accidents happen because the parent was under the influence of drink or drugs, or was ignorant as to how hot a car can get in the sun. But I’d be willing to bet that most parents who find themselves in this terrible situation are just normal folks who were perhaps tired, stressed, in a hurry, and out of their regular routine—as we all are, from time to time.
Losing your beloved child because you were distracted on a bad morning is punishment enough, isn’t it? Will a prison sentence honestly do anyone any good? I mean, we’re not talking about cold-blooded cop killers with a high recidivism rate. But you wouldn’t know that, judging from some of the comments on CNN’s “Sound Off” section just below the story. I see a lot of people there falling all over themselves to assert their superior parenting skills, saying that parents who find themselves in this horrible situation are negligent monsters who don’t really love their children.
Except, that’s total garbage. Yes, children are sometimes left to die in cars by negligent babysitters or ignorant and/or drug-abusing parents. But in the vast majority of cases, the parent responsible for the death is a normal person having a worse than normal morning. Could have been you or me. Let’s hope we never have to find out, and that if we do that the Internet Tough Guys will show a little more mercy.
Discuss: What do you think is an appropriate punishment, if any, for a parent who left his/her child to die in a hot car? And why do you think mothers get punished for this with jail time far more often than fathers? Isn’t that kind of insulting to men, in a way, like we’re holding mothers to a higher standard of parenting than fathers?
Posted in Knocking around the Internet | 7 Comments »

