I’ve been researching a Big Serious Blog Topic for the past week, but I just wanted to take a break from that for a minute to comment on something here. Also to settle bets on whether I’ll ever blog again. Anyhow:
Have you all heard about this? 
Bumbo recalls baby seats after reports of head injuries.
I don’t own one of these seats, but I’ve heard rave reviews from other moms. The seat essentially allows a little baby to “sit up”, even when they’re not otherwise capable of doing so yet.
The product had a sensible warning on the back, for the benefit of those special consumers who regularly use their hair dryers in the bathtub: WARNING: Never use on a raised surface. Never use as a car seat or bath seat. Designed for floor level use only. Never leave your baby unattended as the seat is not designed to be totally restrictive and may not prevent release of your baby in the event of vigorous movement.
But now the seat is being recalled so the manufacturer can tack on one sentence to the beginning of the warning. It now says WARNING: Prevent falls; Never use on any elevated surface. Never use on a raised surface…[etc.]
Okay, maybe I’m missing something here, but is this really necessary? I’m all for good safety labels, but the old one seems fairly clear cut, does it not? Don’t put your baby in a Bumbo on the kitchen counter while you cook dinner because Young Flopsy might fall out. Simple as that. But apparently there are a good number of parents who are okay with baby BASE jumping, because there have been 28 reports of injuries to children who have fallen out of the Bumbo.
Curious, I picked up the phone this morning and called Dan Keeney, a public relations liaison for Bumbo. He said that not all of the reported injuries were from falling off table tops, but most—including three skull fracture incidents—were.
And what about the injuries that happened to kids who weren’t on table tops? From reading the Bumbo parenting forum, it looks like some babies will arch their backs and fall right over the back of the seat. Older babies can plant their feet on the floor and push off, causing the entire seat to fall over backwards. Obviously that could hurt a baby, even when the Bumbo is on the floor. Which seems like all the more reason not to put the baby on a table while sitting in a Bumbo. Or not to put the baby in a Bumbo at all, but I digress.
It appears that one of the women whose child suffered a skull fracture commented on the Bumbo parenting forum. She said: I have read some comments and I want to add that I am very responsible parent. I did put my 3 month on table in seat while seated next to him. I was drawing with my 3 year old and he arched and fell. A skull fracture later I have learned my lesson. It is easier than you think to have a false security about a product such as this. I was right next to him and could do nothing. I think more parents need to be warned about this.
Look, I sympathize with anyone whose child has been injured, but it says right there on the warning label not to leave babies unattended in a Bumbo because they could fall right out. That doesn’t just mean being right next to the baby—it means paying attention and being ready to act, too.
“We’ve promoted this as an extra set of hands,” said Keeney. “But we would never want the parent to be in a position where they can’t reach out and grab the baby if they wiggled out of the Bumbo seat.”
If the company wanted to make a serious effort to improve the safety of the Bumbo, they could redesign it to have a much wider base (sort of like a no-tip dog bowl) and a higher back. But even then, babies could still probably slide out the front through one of the leg slots. Which is why you keep a close eye on them at all times when using a novelty product like this.
You want to argue that the Bumbo is more dangerous than swaddling your baby in bubble wrap, fine. You’ve got a good case. Just don’t say the manufacturers (not to speak of common sense) didn’t warn you.