Oy vey, what a week. Think I need to go to the doctor and get my hemoglobin checked. I feel wiped out all the time; could be the chronic anemia rearing its ugly head again. But, onward and upward! With toothpicks propping up my eyelids if necessary!
So anyway, my knitting suffered greatly last night while I was watching TV. Oh yes it did.
I was kicking back after the kids were in bed, wading through the queue on my DVR as I attempted a hat for my daughter. Unfortunately, I had to frog the whole thing after watching Miss America Reality Check. I was so busy griping about the show that I ended up twisting my stitches dreadfully.
Which brings up the question: why was I watching this if it annoyed me so much? Truth is, I have a thing for watching beauty pageants. Oh, they’re kind of silly, sure, but so is most of the other stuff on TV. And I have no problem with a woman trying to improve her poise, health, articulation, talent, and so forth, as long as that’s not the first priority in her life. There are better ways to be beautiful.
What I have a problem with is the pageant mindset that beauty comes first, and then all the rest of that stuff, like, oh, being smart (as Miss Teen South Carolina 2007 can attest). Or the assumption that beauty takes so much effort. That women should trowel on the makeup, wear stiletto heels and bikinis with their breasts duct taped into a pleasing shape, and go through cans of hairspray in order to win a beauty pageant. I have a problem with the concept that anyone can “win” at beauty, period.
Oh, they can call it a scholarship pageant all they want, and they can call the criteria “good health” or “fitness”, but I’ve not yet seen a fit, talented, articulate, homely girl wearing a sash.
So I was interested to see the promos for Miss America Reality Check last week. After years of low ratings, they said they were going to revolutionize the pageant. All 52 contestants were going to live in a big house together for 10 days as celebrity consultants helped them let go of classic pageant trappings and transform into today’s “It” girl—modern and relatable—before the actual pageant this Saturday.
I’ll give the girls credit: they were willing to step outside their comfort zones, and happy to be given modern hairstyles that didn’t make them look like, as one of the judges put it, “senators’ wives”. No, it was the judges who were driving me crazy. They told the girls to be themselves, be “real”, be “natural”, wear less makeup. Great advice, but the three contestants who best fit that description got smacked down hard.
Miss Vermont is intelligent and beautiful without even trying, but a judge said she looked like she’d just rolled out of bed and advised her to put more effort into hair and makeup. Miss Alaska is gorgeous, very original (her evening gown has huge butterflies printed all over it), and outspoken to a fault—sometimes bothering fellow contestants who aren’t used to that in a beauty queen. So she was chastised for it, but promised to improve. Did make an effort to watch her mouth more. Was then lavished with praise from the judges for being original, but not too original. Then they told her to get rid of her funky legwarmers because she really needed to “look the part”. Whatever happened to being yourself?
And then there’s Miss Utah. Boy, I saved the best for last here. This woman is tough as nails: a Sergeant in the National Guard, a nurse who recently served as a combat medic in the Middle East for a year, and was by all accounts an inspiration to fellow soldiers and scared Afghani women while there. Doesn’t hardly wear make-up, was laughingly clueless about how to strut down the catwalk or flirt with the camera during a photo shoot.
In the first episode the judges told her to wear more makeup; she obliged with a prank: showed up to a contestant event wearing super-hooker makeup, big sparkly earrings, and a (hot pink? can’t remember) bikini. The judges loved it—until someone tipped them off that it was a huge joke. They puffed up like blowfish, sputtering that she was rude and that the Miss America Pageant was “serious business”. They really said that. So of course at the end of that episode, she was chosen as of the “Bottom Three” contestants. They broke it to her gently by first complimenting her for taking charge when a fellow contestant had a bad asthma attack. But never mind that, she was in the Bottom Three because she had tipped the sacred cow of the judges’ own self-importance. Yup, those are some fine priorities right there.
I mean, I thought they were shooting for “relatable”, and nothing is more relatable than a woman staring at the camera and confessing, “I do not know what I am doing.”
So all in all the new Miss America Pageant is the same old hustle with a new haircut. I’ll pass.